Talkietones: modems

Klik hier voor de Nederlandse versie

Logo

 
TalkieTones requires that your modem can send and receive DTMF tones, associated with the phone keys 0 to 9, # and *. These days most analog modems can do this, but as far as I know this is not the case for ISDN and ADSL modems.

To receive text from a text phone, the modem must be able to detect incoming tones at a rate of just over 10 tones per second. This places a heavy burden on the modem. Or worse, if you have a so called 'soft' modem it places a heavy burden on the computer itself. If modem or computer can not keep track of incoming tones at this rate then the received text will be corrupted, possibly beyond recognition.

The following list is based on the experiences of users with some modems, when used in combination with TalkieTones. There is however no guarantee that the same type of modem will give the same results when used in a different computer, or with a different driver or firmware. In particular for 'soft' modems the type and speed of the computer's processor can be expected to make a difference.

Move the mouse cursor over the icons in the list to see their meaning.

Brand

Type

Modem properties

Performance

Comments

Receive

Send

Diamond

Supra Express 56i V Pro

analog modem

internal modem

modem with DSP processor

good performance

good performance

'Controllerless' modem

Dynalink

1456UT 56kbps USB voice/fax/modem

analog modem

external modem

modem with DSP processor

good performance

good performance

 

Sweex

CA000030 56k hardware PCI modem

analog modem

internal modem

modem with DSP processor

good performance

good performance

Limited experiece with the reception text; seems to work fine

Hayes

V.92 PCI faxmodem

analog modem

internal modem

modem with DSP processor

reasonable performance

good performance

Some errors in the received text

Zoom

V.92 PCI faxmodem

analog modem

internal modem

modem with DSP processor

reasonable performance

good performance

Same modem hardware as the Hayes V.92 PCI faxmodem; some errors in the received text

Eicon

DIVA Mobile V.90

analog modemISDN modem

PCMCIA modem

?

reasonable performance

good performance

Some errors in the received text

Safeway (Tiny?)

HSP56 Micromodem

analog modem

internal modem

modem without DSP processor

reasonable performance

good performance

Some errors in the received text; this is the first 'soft' modem for which acceptable reception was reported

Intel

56k HaM data/fax/voice

analog modem

?

modem with DSP processor

good performance

poor performance

'Controllerless' modem;  sends the DTMF tone for the # key incorrectly (reported by one user)

Sweex

CA100010 56k RS232 serial modem

analog modem

external modem

modem with DSP processor

poor performance

good performance

 

Sitecom

DC-002 56k Advanced PCI Modem

analog modem

internal modem

modem with DSP processor

poor performance

good performance

'Controllerless' modem

Conexant

MR56PVS-RSI 56K PCI Speakerphone

analog modem

internal modem

modem without DSP processor

poor performance

good performance

'Soft' modem; tried on a computer with 450 MHz Pentium 3 processor

Motorola

56K PCI speakerphone

analog modem

internal modem

modem without DSP processor

poor performance

good performance

'Soft' modem; same chipset as Conexant MR56PVS-RSI 56K PCI Speakerphone

Safeway

SW-56-M-PCI fax/voice/speakerphone (SM 56 PCI)

analog modem

internal modem

modem without DSP processor

poor performance

good performance

'Soft' modem

E-Tech

E56KRVP-D or E56KRX

analog modem

external modem

modem with DSP processor

-

-

Modem has no voice capabilities, so can not receive DTMF tones

Diamond

SUPRA SST 56i PRO DF PCI (SUP2850)

analog modem

internal modem

modem without DSP processor

-

-

Modem has no voice capabilities, so can not receive DTMF tones

Compaq

56K V.90 MiniPCI

analog modem

internal modem

?

-

-

Standard in Compaq Armada E500 laptop; modem has no voice capabilities, so can not receive DTMF tones

Teles

S0/PCI or Vision B5

ISDN modem

internal modem

 -

 -

 -

Does not support DTMF tones

Teles

BRI/16.3

ISDN modem

internal modem

 -

 -

 -

Does not support DTMF tones

Tornado

probably Tipa P

ISDN modem

internal modem

 -

 -

 -

Does not support DTMF tones

The list is still short and the search for the 'ideal' modem has only just begun. Send me an email with your modem type and experiences if you too have tried out TalkieTones. I will then add the information to the list.


Top of page

Bugs in the Netscape 6 browser distort most pages of this site. If this annoys you, use Internet Explorer, Netscape Communicator/Navigator or Opera instead. © All material on this site is owned by Berend Meijer. You are not allowed to copy any of the text, images, music, sounds, scripts or other contents unless you get his permission first. You are also not allowed to use any of the text, images, music, sounds, scripts or other contents outside the context of this site.